Collectors who say they lost more than $6.7 million on forged Andy Warhol works told a federal judge in Miami that a Pennsylvania gallery and its principal were "an integral part" of the scheme.

Richard and Judy Perlman answered an October 23 request by Dane Fine Art and Nathan Isen to split the claims against them and move them to federal court in Philadelphia, according to court records reviewed by Urgent Matter.

Dane and Isen deny the claims and told Judge David S. Leibowitz that Dane bought the Warhols it sold to Leslie Roberts' Miami Fine Art Gallery at Christie's, Doyle and Rago.

Roberts pleaded guilty to conspiracy to commit wire fraud and was sentenced in October to 46 months in federal prison, the U.S. Attorney's Office in Miami said. Prosecutors said he sold forged Warhols with fake foundation invoices, forged authentication papers and counterfeit stamps.

The Perlmans say Roberts sold them the works as pieces he bought directly from the Andy Warhol Foundation for the Visual Arts. Much of that pitch came through "Alex Herman," whom they describe as a fake foundation employee Roberts invented.

Their lawsuit accuses Dane, Isen and six others of supplying the fakes.

Isen texted Roberts in June 2023 to say he had "the queen all ready for u in Boca [Raton, Florida] for pick up," the Perlmans wrote. They said he meant a purported Warhol Queen Margrethe II that Roberts' gallery later sold to the family.

Isen told the gallery a purported Warhol Sarah Bernhardt had to be sold so he could "get out of Hock," the Perlmans wrote. They said Isen also objected when Roberts planned to put a White Queen from Dane up for auction to keep the work away from independent experts.

The Perlmans wrote that Dane invoiced Roberts' gallery for a purported Warhol Paloma Picasso on May 2, 2024, and that Herman offered the family the same work seven days later.

Herman priced it at $38,000 but said a $20,000 credit from its previous owner let him "close it out to you for 18,000," the Perlmans said in an earlier lawsuit. They say that previous owner was Isen and Dane.

In an email to the Herman account, Roberts wrote, "I know Dane owes alot to you in past commitments," the Perlmans said.

The family's 401K plan paid $9,000 on May 13, 2024, for a half share of the Paloma Picasso, records from the earlier suit show. Roberts' gallery listed the work's cost as $18,000.

"Dane's motion does not address these allegations," the Perlmans wrote.

They called the auction records and other material Dane filed "a hodge-podge of extrinsic evidence that is neither timely nor relevant" before any records were exchanged.

Dane and Isen answered that the messages do not tie them to the fake foundation story Roberts told the family. Their lawyers described the Boca text as “Isen’s shipment of art for pickup in Boca.”

“None of these communications reference the Foundation or denote any such representation,” they wrote in a reply. They said all of Dane’s communications took place in Philadelphia.

The reply says the complaint accuses Dane of selling works to Roberts’ gallery, having “manufactured at least some of them” and “provid[ed] false documentation.”

Dane's lawyers wrote in October that the complaint does not allege Dane or Isen ever dealt with any of the other defendants. "Plaintiffs already know the claims against the Dane Defendants are meritless, and new discovery will further prove it," they wrote.

Kristopher Isen, Dane's managing partner, said in a sworn declaration that "Dane Fine Art did not supply forgeries to Leslie Roberts as alleged." He wrote that the gallery "did not knowingly sell counterfeit works or provide forged authentication documentation" to Roberts' gallery.

The complaint accuses Dane of selling Roberts' gallery three forged prints of Warhol's The Witch in October 2023, Dane's lawyers wrote. Dane says it sold two, both authentic.

Dane's records show it bought one at Christie's on April 20, 2023, for $74,844 with fees and tax. Christie's described the print, from Warhol's 1981 "Myths" series, as a unique trial proof with diamond dust, numbered TP 18/30.

Dane bought the other at Rago, in Lambertville, New Jersey, on October 12, 2023, for $41,580. Rago's invoice is addressed to Nathan Isen at I Brewster & Company Inc. in Philadelphia.

Dane billed Roberts' gallery for both prints on October 16, 2023, at $79,850 and $49,500.

The complaint also accuses Dane of selling the gallery a forged Cow and a forged Truck, the lawyers wrote. Doyle, in Manhattan, invoiced Kristopher Isen for both on November 1, 2023, at $10,080 for the Cow and $44,100 for the Truck, listed as signed and numbered 47/60.

Dane billed Roberts' gallery $46,600 for the Truck on November 11, 2023, with the note "provenance: Martin Lawrence sticker on back."

Kristopher Isen wrote that some works described in the complaint do not match the edition numbers, proof markings or colors in Dane's records. "Works sharing a Warhol image are not necessarily the same physical impression," he wrote.

He wrote that Dane later bought back some works it had sold Roberts' gallery and resold some at Rago. Dane's lawyers wrote that some art in the suit is back in Pennsylvania "since it is original and valuable and not forged as Plaintiffs contend."

Dane bought an estimated 80% of its Warhols from Christie's over the years, Kristopher Isen wrote. "Works by Andy Warhol and other Pop Art artists form an important part of Dane Fine Art's business," he wrote.

Nathan Isen was sentenced in federal court in Philadelphia in 2015 to three years' probation, 320 hours of community service and a $15,000 fine on a money laundering charge, court records show.

Federal prosecutors said Isen, then 61 and living in Villanova, sold 12 artworks for $20,000 in cash he understood came from marijuana sales. The case came from an ICE investigation.

The other defendants are Oscar Cordova, Allan Dampf, WarholandFriends LLC and Edward Kurstak, all in Florida, and Luis Alberto Pulido Torres and Mario Huapaya in Peru.

The Perlmans accuse Cordova of providing fake canvases and say purported Warhol "trial proofs" came from Dampf and WarholandFriends. They accuse Kurstak of providing forgeries and stamping phony authentication on works from elsewhere.

Pulido Torres and Huapaya, they say, produced forgeries in Peru sent to Roberts' gallery. Dane's lawyers wrote the complaint puts some of those prices as low as $30.

The Perlmans make six claims against all eight defendants, including aiding and abetting fraud, conspiracy and racketeering under federal and Florida law. They want the defendants held liable together for the full losses.

They filed the suit September 9 in the Complex Business Litigation Division of Miami-Dade Circuit Court. Dane moved it to federal court October 9.

Prosecutors said Roberts recruited Carlos Miguel Rodriguez Melendez to pose as an employee of a New York auction house and vouch for the forgeries. Rodriguez Melendez also pleaded guilty to conspiracy to commit wire fraud and was sentenced in September 2025 to a year of probation and $5,000 in restitution, court records show.

The Perlmans settled with Roberts and his gallery on confidential terms and ended their earlier suit January 12, records show. Dane and the other defendants in the new suit were not parties to it.

Dane's lawyers argued the claims against the gallery belong in Pennsylvania because its staff live and work in southeastern Pennsylvania, its records and some disputed works are there, and the auction-house witnesses it plans to call work nearer Philadelphia than Miami.

The Perlmans countered that Christie's and Doyle both have Palm Beach locations and that Rago does regular business in the district, so their staff could testify in Miami. They wrote that the art Dane bought back "has already traveled from Pennsylvania to Florida and back again."

Dane's lawyers argued a Pennsylvania trial would not be a hardship for the Perlmans, who they said "have substantial net worth given their status as avid art collectors and claims to have spent nearly $7 million on art from [Miami Fine Art Gallery] alone."

The Perlmans answered that Nathan Isen "holds himself out as a sophisticated and wealthy art dealer."

FBI agents were seen working outside Dane Fine Art's gallery on Haverford Road on July 29, 6abc reported. The FBI told the station it was conducting "court authorized law enforcement activity" and did not give other details.

Dane asked Leibowitz on October 16 to throw out the complaint, and Nathan Isen joined the request.

On October 28, the Perlmans asked Leibowitz to set one briefing schedule for all defendants. Dane and Nathan Isen objected the same day, saying their request to dismiss the case should not wait until the Perlmans serve defendants they have not yet reached.

Dane’s lawyers asked Leibowitz to hear oral argument on moving the case. They wrote that their motion to dismiss has sat unanswered since October 16 and that the Perlmans have “inexplicably failed to serve” some defendants more than two months after suing.

Urgent Matter is reader-supported. Please consider subscribing to support independent arts journalism. 

Share this article
The link has been copied!