The art, antiques and collectibles at Clearwater Seafoods co-founder John Risley's collapsed investment firm dropped from C$26.8 million on the company's books in 2024 to C$8.1 million by the end of 2025, a Nova Scotia judge wrote in a September ruling.

Risley says 669 of the firm's 1,281 artworks, ranging from Maud Lewis paintings to a beaded Plains Cree belt, are his personally. Justice John A. Keith of the Supreme Court of Nova Scotia wrote that he had "virtually no evidence or information" about how or why that claim "came to light."

Risley's share grew over the summer. In June, FTI Consulting Canada, the firm the court appointed to oversee the case, counted 539 pieces on his side, about 42% of the collection. By August, it rose to 669, about 52%.

"I do not know, and have no evidence regarding, how/why the allocation to Mr. Risley increased," Keith wrote.

Paid subscribers can read the documents used in this reporting.

Court Documents: CFFI Ventures art dispute
Court decisions, monitor's reports and orders from the CFFI Ventures CCAA case in the Supreme Court of Nova Scotia

Keith wrote that most of the drop in value comes from a C$11.2 million write-down linked to a suggestion that the company paid more for the works than they are worth now.

The rest came mostly from art CFFI sold in 2025. Those sales brought in C$2.66 million and caused a C$4.87 million loss. The numbers come from CFFI's unaudited financial statements, as summarized by FTI.

CFFI, based in Bedford, Nova Scotia, went under court protection from its creditors on March 13, Canada's rough equivalent of Chapter 11 bankruptcy. It owed about US$1.12 billion to a group of lenders led by the investment firm HPS Investment Partners, documents show.

On October 1, New Tide Capital, an affiliate of those lenders, took over most of what CFFI owned. It didn't pay cash but took on the debt instead, documents show.

Keith wrote that CFFI's unsecured creditors, the ones with no claim on any specific asset, will get nothing.

The art went to New Tide too, but only the pieces CFFI actually owns. Keith called Risley the company's "principal directing mind."

Risley's claim rests on a "general agreement" he reached with the company around 2025, FTI reported. Anything bought before July 1, 2004, plus certain works given to him as gifts, belongs to him.

Anything bought after that date stays with CFFI.

FTI said the deal was never formalized and was still being negotiated. It might also need approvals nobody had gotten yet.

Keith wrote he didn't know who worked out the deal or when. He also couldn't say how Risley's claim affected the collection's value.

FTI told the court that the line between CFFI's spending and Risley's personal spending "was not strictly maintained." Keith wrote that nobody explained how that played out with the art, including "who made the gift."

CFFI hired an outside art firm, The Kalaman Group, in 2023 to catalog the collection, inspect most pieces, organize purchase records and ownership histories, and handle logistics and "custody transitions," Keith wrote.

In February 2026, Ernst & Young hired Kalaman to estimate what the art would sell for at retail. That same month, Kalaman wrote CFFI a memo titled "Directional Fair Market Value Commentary – CFFI Art Collection."

Keith wrote that the memo "was not disclosed" in the court papers he was ruling on.

FTI decided not to bring in its own appraiser, Keith wrote, because the art was a small part of the assets at stake and the debt was so large.

"That said and even accepting the smallest valuation put in evidence before me, the book value of the artwork is $8.1 million which is hardly a trifling amount," he wrote. "Many persons come before this Court debating much smaller amounts."

The order first put before Keith would have let Risley and the lender keep negotiating and split the art privately. Keith wrote that a court in a case like this "neither serves as a rubber stamp nor stands passively by" while disputes get settled privately "on the basis of the Court's pre-emptive blessing."

HPS and New Tide dispute that they are related to CFFI but agreed to be treated as related parties for the hearing. Keith wrote that he therefore did not look at the art question "as if the parties in question are acting at arms-length from one another."

He wrote that what he was given was "insufficient to reasonably consider (let alone confirm)" what Risley was claiming.

Keith also wrote that he agreed with HPS's lawyer, Marc Wasserman, that a court shouldn't "insinuate itself into settlement discussion," and that making the parties report back may work better.

The final order, signed September 28, lets Risley keep fighting for the disputed works, but only in Keith's courtroom.

It also requires New Tide to hand FTI a written "Artwork Report" on any deal where Risley buys disputed pieces or gets them as gifts. The report must explain "the legal and practical basis" for the deal and include any valuations reasonably available.

The report is due by November 27. FTI then has 14 days, or longer if the court allows, to submit it to the court with its own comments.

Risley told FTI he will not stand in the way of the disputed works going to New Tide, the monitor reported in August.

The full list of the 669 disputed works, filed with FTI's August report, runs 12 pages. It gives each piece's inventory number, artist, title, medium and type. It doesn't give values.

There are 373 paintings, 121 sculptures, 67 textiles, 48 prints and 34 items labeled "Cultural Object," plus drawings, photographs, ceramics, baskets and a book.

Maud Lewis, the Nova Scotia folk painter, accounts for 93 entries, including two paintings both titled Train Station in Winter.

From the Group of Seven, the Canadian landscape painters, there's A.Y. Jackson's Margaree Harbour, Cape Breton, Nova Scotia, Arthur Lismer's Coquillages (Shellfish) and three Nova Scotia scenes by J.E.H. MacDonald: The Churches, Broad Cove, NS, Fisherman's Bay and Low Tide, Petite Rivière, NS.

The list also has James Wilson Morrice's Le Pont d'Austerlitz and The Ferry, Paul Peel's Before the Bath, Mary Pratt's Silver Fish on Crimson Foil and three works by Christopher Pratt. Two untitled abstract paintings are credited to an "Unknown" artist, each with a "possible attribution" to Jean-Paul Riopelle.

The Plains Cree belt is made of glass beads and buffalo hide, and the list describes it as being from the Battle of Batoche. It sits alongside a "Carved Haida Box," Mi'kmaq quillwork boxes, a circular ceremonial panel attributed to the "Mi'kmaq school" and two pairs of children's moccasins.

There's also a child's parka by Jessie Oonark, a men's ceremonial parka by Angie Angmak Eetak, a beaded amauti from Arviat, Innu tea dolls by Angela Andrews and a trade silver gorget by William James Veith.

When New Tide took over, the deal assigned US$25 million of CFFI's debt to the company's physical property, a category that covers furniture, equipment, artwork and the like. FTI's closing paperwork lists the assets still waiting to move to New Tide. None of them is art.

CFFI's court protection runs through December 18.

Urgent Matter is reader-supported. Please consider subscribing to support independent arts journalism.

Share this article
The link has been copied!