The Eric Carle Museum of Picture Book Art wants two jobs removed from its staff’s new union, records obtained by Urgent Matter show.

The museum told the National Labor Relations Board that workers in two job titles are supervisors: the collections manager and chief registrar, and the art educator. Federal labor law excludes supervisors from the groups of workers the board certifies a union to bargain for.

Eric Carle, the author and illustrator of The Very Hungry Caterpillar, founded the museum in Amherst, Massachusetts, with his wife, Barbara, in 2002. Its staff voted 23-4 in August to join Local 2110 of the United Auto Workers.

Executive Director Jennifer Schantz signed the one-page petition September 18, two weeks after the board certified the union on September 4. The board docketed the petition September 28.

In the space for the museum’s reason, the petition says, “The job classifications are supervisors.”

Paid subscribers can read the petition.

FOIA Documents: Eric Carle Museum’s NLRB petition
Documents released to Urgent Matter by the National Labor Relations Board on November 19, 2026.

The petition says the union’s bargaining unit has 31 workers now and would have 29 without the two titles. The form asks how many workers hold each title, but the museum left that part blank.

The NLRB released the petition to Urgent Matter in full Thursday in response to a Freedom of Information Act request. The case is open in the board’s Boston regional office, and its public docket does not show any action since the filing.

Workers announced the union drive August 3, when Local 2110 petitioned for an election covering 36 workers. On that day, staff called on museum leadership “to agree to an inclusive voter eligibility list” in an Instagram post.

The two jobs went into the vote unsettled. Under an election agreement dated August 11, workers in both titles could cast ballots, but those ballots “may be challenged since their eligibility has not been resolved,” the NLRB’s case page shows.

The agreement said the question “will be resolved, if necessary, following the election.”

The board’s tally shows three ballots were challenged, too few to change the outcome.

The UAW announced the win in an August 28 post on its website. The union said staff organized over pay, health and safety, few chances for promotion and job security.

Under the NLRB’s election procedures, challenged ballots that can’t change a result “are never opened and no determination is made on the voters’ eligibility.” The museum’s petition now asks the board to decide where the two jobs belong.

The U.S. Supreme Court has upheld the board’s rule that whoever claims a worker is a supervisor has to prove it. In this case, that’s the museum.

Federal law defines a supervisor as someone with authority over other employees, such as the power to hire, fire, discipline, assign or “responsibly to direct” them, using “independent judgment” and not in a “merely routine or clerical” way.

The board said in a 2015 decision that job descriptions and job titles, “without more, do not demonstrate supervisory authority.”

A December 2024 ad for the collections manager and chief registrar job, reposted on New York University’s museum studies job board, said the position “directly supervises associate and assistant registrar, work-study students and interns.” The ad listed pay of $60,000 to $75,000 and said the chief curator oversees the job.

An assistant registrar listing still on the museum’s website, for a full-time hourly job paying $22 to $26 an hour, says that worker reports to the collections manager and chief registrar.

The museum’s art educator listing, with a May 1 application date, describes one of two art educator jobs as full-time and hourly, paying $25.57 to $29.23 an hour.

The art educators “lead a team of approximately 30 Art Studio Assistants, volunteers, work-study students, and interns," according to the listings.

The art educators oversee that team and seasonal or temporary support staff, “providing orientation, daily scheduling and ongoing supervision,” the listing says. They also help recruit and select them.

The background the listing asks for includes a year of supervisory experience.

The museum’s current listing for art studio assistants offers $17.50 an hour for up to 14 hours a week. The listing says the assistants work under the museum’s art educators.

Howard Robbins of the New York law firm Proskauer Rose is listed as the museum’s lawyer on the petition. NLRB records show that Robbins and Proskauer’s Michael Kratochvil represented the museum in the election case.

Robbins’ firm biography lists the Metropolitan Opera and the Museum of Modern Art among the clients he represents, along with “many other major museums and cultural institutions from coast to coast.”

Dana Lossia of Levy Ratner, who represented the union in the election case, is listed as the union’s lawyer in the new case.

The petition says no union contract has been negotiated.

Local 2110 has its own unit clarification case at another museum.

In April 2025, the union asked the board to add five job titles to its unit at the American Folk Art Museum in New York. That case is still open, its docket shows.

Urgent Matter is reader-supported. Please consider subscribing to support independent arts journalism.   

Share this article
The link has been copied!